21-Ford - Receive the item (Did not carry)
12/7/2009 3:02:18 PM “PG33.10 - Receive the item”
6 yea+36 nay,failed,quorum
12/7/2009 3:02:18 PM “PG33.10 - Receive the item” 6 yea+36 nay,failed,quorum
YES Ainslie YES Del Grande YES Ford YES Minnan-Wong YES Nunziata YES Ootes NO Ashton NO Augimeri NO Bussin [Chair] NO Carroll NO Cho NO Davis NO De Baeremaeker NO Di Giorgio NO Filion NO Fletcher NO Giambrone NO Grimes NO Hall NO Heaps NO Holyday NO Jenkins NO Kelly NO Lee NO Lindsay Luby NO Mammoliti NO McConnell NO Mihevc NO Milczyn NO Miller NO Moeser NO Moscoe NO Palacio NO Parker NO Perks NO Perruzza NO Rae NO Saundercook NO Stintz NO Thompson NO Vaughan NO Walker
Motions Concerning the By-Law Provisions
9 - Motion to Amend Motion moved by Councillor Peter Milczyn (Carried)
That Part 1.d of Councillor Kelly's motion be referred to the Deputy City Manager, Cluster B, to address in his one year review of the new by-law;
12/7/2009 3:03:41 PM “PG33.10 - Milczyn 9” 25 yea+17 nay,carried,quorum
YES Ainslie YES Ashton YES Carroll YES Cho YES Davis YES Di Giorgio YES Ford YES Grimes YES Heaps YES Jenkins YES Kelly YES Lindsay Luby YES Milczyn YES Miller YES Minnan-Wong YES Moscoe YES Nunziata YES Ootes YES Palacio YES Parker YES Perks YES Rae YES Saundercook YES Thompson YES Walker NO Augimeri NO Bussin [Chair] NO De Baeremaeker NO Del Grande NO Filion NO Fletcher NO Giambrone NO Hall NO Holyday NO Lee NO Mammoliti NO McConnell NO Mihevc NO Moeser NO Perruzza NO Stintz NO Vaughan
13a - Motion to Amend Motion moved by Councillor Glenn De Baeremaeker (Carried)
That Part 1(e) of Motion 1 by Councillor Kelly be amended by deleting "the hours of 1:00 a.m and 5:00 a.m" and inserting instead, "the hours of 11:00 p.m. and 7:00 a.m."
12/7/2009 3:05:25 PM “PG33.10 - Motion 13A” 34 yea+8 nay,2/3 maj,quorum
YES Ainslie YES Augimeri YES Bussin [Chair] YES Carroll YES Cho YES Davis YES De Baeremaeker YES Del Grande YES Di Giorgio YES Filion YES Fletcher YES Giambrone YES Hall YES Heaps YES Jenkins YES Lindsay Luby YES Mammoliti YES McConnell YES Mihevc YES Milczyn YES Miller YES Minnan-Wong YES Moeser YES Moscoe YES Nunziata YES Palacio YES Parker YES Perks YES Perruzza YES Rae YES Saundercook YES Thompson YES Vaughan YES Walker NO Ashton NO Ford NO Grimes NO Holyday NO Kelly NO Lee NO Ootes NO Stintz
Part 1 of 1 - Motion to Amend Item moved by Councillor Norman Kelly as Amended by Milczyn 9 and De Baremaeker 13A
That City Council adopt the recommendations contained in the supplementary report (November 27, 2009) from the Deputy City Manager, Cluster B, and the Deputy City Manager and Chief Financial Officer [PG33.10b], with the following amendments:
1. The draft sign by-law attached to the report (Appendix A – Revised Appendix A) be amended:
a. by deleting all reference to the prohibition of signs “within 30 metres of an intersection” and replacing it with “within 6 metres of an intersection”;
b. by deleting “5 years” and replacing it with “10 years” in Subsection 694-9 B, so that the Subsection now reads:
“B. Every sign permit issued by the Chief Building Official for the erection or display of a third party sign shall expire ten years from the date of issuance and is null and void on its expiry date”;
and that Subsection 694-9 C be correspondinglyamended to refer to "10 years"
c. by deleting all reference to wall sign height not exceeding “15 metres” and replacing it with “20 metres”;
d. by amendingSection 694-22.A by adding " and electronic static copy", so the subsection now reads:
"A. Third party signs are permitted to display mechanical copy and electronic static copy"; and
e. by deleting “Illumination between the hours of 11 p.m. and 6 a.m.” and replacing it with “Illumination between the hours of 1:00 a.m. and 5:00 a.m.” in subsection 694-18 C, so that the Subsection now reads:
C. No sign shall be illuminated between the hours of 1:00 a.m. and 5:00 a.m. except where:
1. the sign is a first party sign associated with a lawful business which operates during this period and only while the business is actually in operation; or
2. the sign is located in the Downtown Yonge Street Special Sign District, the Dundas Square Special Sign District, or the Gardiner Gateway Special Sign District.
Vote on Parts 1a, 1b and 1C of Kelly Motion 1 (Did not carry)
12/7/2009 3:11:14 PM “PG33.10 - Kelly 1 - Part 1 a, b, c” 15 yea+26 nay,failed,quorum
YES Bussin [Chair] YES Di Giorgio YES Ford YES Grimes YES Kelly YES Lee YES Lindsay Luby YES Mammoliti YES Minnan-Wong YES Nunziata YES Ootes YES Palacio YES Parker YES Saundercook YES Stintz NO Ainslie NO Ashton NO Augimeri NO Carroll NO Cho NO Davis NO De Baeremaeker NO Del Grande NO Filion NO Fletcher NO Giambrone NO Hall NO Heaps NO Holyday NO Jenkins NO McConnell NO Mihevc NO Milczyn NO Miller NO Moeser NO Moscoe NO Perks NO Perruzza NO Rae NO Vaughan NO Walker
Part D was referred by Milczyn.
Vote on Part 1e of Kelly 1, as amended by De Baeremaeker 13a (Carried)
12/7/2009 3:12:39 PM “PG33.10 - Kelly 1 - Part 1 e as amended” 31 yea+10 nay,2/3 maj,quorum
YES Ainslie YES Augimeri YES Bussin [Chair] YES Carroll YES Cho YES Davis YES De Baeremaeker YES Del Grande YES Di Giorgio YES Filion YES Fletcher YES Giambrone YES Heaps YES Jenkins YES Lindsay Luby YES Mammoliti YES McConnell YES Mihevc YES Milczyn YES Miller YES Minnan-Wong YES Moeser YES Moscoe YES Nunziata YES Palacio YES Parker YES Perks YES Perruzza YES Rae YES Vaughan YES Walker NO Ashton NO Ford NO Grimes NO Hall NO Holyday NO Kelly NO Lee NO Ootes NO Saundercook NO Stintz
6a - Part 1 Motion to Amend Item (Additional) moved by Councillor Howard Moscoe (Did Not Carry)
That:
1. the new sign regulations prohibit third party electronic fuel pump signs;
12/7/2009 3:14:08 PM “PG33.10 - Moscoe 6A part 1” 20 yea+21 nay,failed,quorum
YES Ainslie YES Augimeri YES Bussin [Chair] YES Cho YES Davis YES De Baeremaeker YES Filion YES Fletcher YES Giambrone YES Hall YES McConnell YES Mihevc YES Miller YES Minnan-Wong YES Moeser YES Moscoe YES Palacio YES Perks YES Perruzza YES Vaughan NO Ashton NO Carroll NO Del Grande NO Di Giorgio NO Ford NO Grimes NO Heaps NO Holyday NO Jenkins NO Kelly NO Lee NO Lindsay Luby NO Mammoliti NO Milczyn NO Nunziata NO Ootes NO Parker NO Rae NO Saundercook NO Stintz NO Walker
6a - Part 2 Motion to Amend Item (Additional) moved by Councillor Howard Moscoe (Carried)
that:
2. electronic fuel pump signs be limited in their application to no more than 50 percent of the fuel pumps on any particular property;
12/7/2009 3:15:07 PM “PG33.10 - Moscoe 6a - Part 2” 21 yea+20 nay,carried,quorum
YES Ainslie YES Augimeri YES Bussin [Chair] YES Cho YES Davis YES De Baeremaeker YES Di Giorgio YES Filion YES Fletcher YES Giambrone YES Hall YES Heaps YES McConnell YES Mihevc YES Miller YES Moeser YES Moscoe YES Palacio YES Perks YES Perruzza YES Vaughan NO Ashton NO Carroll NO Del Grande NO Ford NO Grimes NO Holyday NO Jenkins NO Kelly NO Lee NO Lindsay Luby NO Mammoliti NO Milczyn NO Minnan-Wong NO Nunziata NO Ootes NO Parker NO Rae NO Saundercook NO Stintz NO Walker
6a - Part 3 Motion to Amend Item (Additional) moved by Councillor Howard Moscoe (Carried)
That:
3. the notification provisions which are proposed for owners, be also extended to business and residential tenants and such additional notification may be by way of postal drop or bill distribution all at the expense of the applicant.
12/7/2009 3:16:03 PM “PG33.10 - Moscoe 6A - Part 3” 30 yea+11 nay,2/3 maj,quorum
YES Ainslie YES Ashton YES Augimeri YES Bussin [Chair] YES Carroll YES Cho YES Davis YES De Baeremaeker YES Del Grande YES Filion YES Fletcher YES Giambrone YES Hall YES Heaps YES Holyday YES Jenkins YES Kelly YES Lee YES McConnell YES Mihevc YES Milczyn YES Miller YES Moeser YES Moscoe YES Nunziata YES Palacio YES Perks YES Perruzza YES Vaughan YES Walker NO Di Giorgio NO Ford NO Grimes NO Lindsay Luby NO Mammoliti NO Minnan-Wong NO Ootes NO Parker NO Rae NO Saundercook NO Stintz
7 - Motion to Amend Item (Additional) moved by Councillor Suzan Hall (Carried)
That Subsection 694.6 A (3) of the draft sign by-law appended to the report (November 27, 2009) from the Deputy City Manager, Cluster B and the Deputy City Manager and Chief Financial Officer be amended by adding the words "or BIA", so that the subsection now reads:
"(3) A sign erected by a charitable, cultural or community organization, or BIA, for the purpose of advertising events held or sponsored by such organization, provided:"
- Adopted on a show of hands
13b - Motion to Amend Item (Additional) moved by Councillor Glenn De Baeremaeker (Did Not Carry)
That Subsection 694-2, Scope, of the draft sign by-law appended to the report (November 27, 2009) from the Deputy City Manager, Cluster B and the Deputy City Manager and Chief Financial Officer be amended by adding a new Subsection 10 to read:
"(10) signs on railway bridges located at the intersection of St. Clair Avenue West and Davenport Road and the intersection of St. Clair Avenue West and Caledonia Road"
12/7/2009 3:18:17 PM “PG33.10 - 13B De Baeremaeker” 15 yea+26 nay,failed,quorum
YES Augimeri YES De Baeremaeker YES Del Grande YES Di Giorgio YES Kelly YES Lindsay Luby YES Mammoliti YES Miller YES Nunziata YES Ootes YES Palacio YES Parker YES Perruzza YES Rae YES Saundercook NO Ainslie NO Ashton NO Bussin [Chair] NO Carroll NO Cho NO Davis NO Filion NO Fletcher NO Ford NO Giambrone NO Grimes NO Hall NO Heaps NO Holyday NO Jenkins NO Lee NO McConnell NO Mihevc NO Milczyn NO Minnan-Wong NO Moeser NO Moscoe NO Perks NO Stintz NO Vaughan NO Walker
15 - Motion to Amend Item moved by Councillor Mike Del Grande (Carried)
That the Sign by-law and Sign Tax be applied to both public (ie. TTC, the City of Toronto etc.) and private signs.
12/7/2009 3:19:22 PM “PG33.10 - Del Grande 15” 13 yea+28 nay,failed,quorum
YES Del Grande YES Grimes YES Jenkins YES Lee YES Mammoliti YES Minnan-Wong YES Nunziata YES Palacio YES Parker YES Rae YES Saundercook YES Stintz YES Walker NO Ainslie NO Ashton NO Augimeri NO Bussin [Chair] NO Carroll NO Cho NO Davis NO De Baeremaeker NO Di Giorgio NO Filion NO Fletcher NO Ford NO Giambrone NO Hall NO Heaps NO Holyday NO Kelly NO Lindsay Luby NO McConnell NO Mihevc NO Milczyn NO Miller NO Moeser NO Moscoe NO Ootes NO Perks NO Perruzza NO Vaughan
19c - Motion to Amend Item moved by Councillor Adam Vaughan (Carried)
That no new outdoor advertising concepts be executed or permitted unless specifically identified in the by-law, and that any approach to outdoor advertising be submitted to staff and approved by Council before production and display.
12/7/2009 3:20:47 PM “PG33.10 - Vaughan 19C” 26 yea+15 nay,carried,quorum
YES Ainslie YES Ashton YES Augimeri YES Bussin [Chair] YES Cho YES Davis YES De Baeremaeker YES Filion YES Fletcher YES Giambrone YES Hall YES Heaps YES Holyday YES Jenkins YES Lee YES Mammoliti YES McConnell YES Mihevc YES Miller YES Moeser YES Moscoe YES Palacio YES Perks YES Perruzza YES Vaughan YES Walker NO Carroll NO Del Grande NO Di Giorgio NO Ford NO Grimes NO Kelly NO Lindsay Luby NO Milczyn NO Minnan-Wong NO Nunziata NO Ootes NO Parker NO Rae NO Saundercook NO Stintz
6c - Motion to Refer Motion moved by Councillor Howard Moscoe (Carried)
That Motion 4 by Councillor Mammoliti be referred to the Chief Building Official and Executive Director, Toronto Building for a report to the Planning and Growth Committee.
- NB: Motion 4 was a motion by Councillor Mammoliti to establish a new sign distrct for Emery Village
Sign Variance Committee Motions
11 - Motion to Amend Item moved by Councillor Chin Lee (Carried)
That Bullet Point 5 of Appendix H (Qualifications of Members of the Sign Variance Committee) be amended to read as follows:
- at least 3 members have adjudication experience and 2 members have public speaking and organizational skills, to be able to chair meetings public meetings and maintain order in conflict situations.
- Adopted on a show of hands
17a - Motion to Amend Item (Additional) moved by Councillor Cliff Jenkins (Carried)
1. That Recommendation 7 of the Planning and Growth Management Committee be amended to now read:
"7. City Council delegate to the Sign Variance Committee the authority to make final decisions on the hearing of appeals of the Chief Building Official’s decisions,on first party sign variance applications and to make decisions on third party sign variance applications in accordance with the criteria for evaluating applications for variances set out in Appendix A to the report (October 20, 2009) from the Deputy City Manager, Cluster B and the Deputy City Manager and Chief Financial Officer, subject to an appeal in respect of approved variances only, at the instance of the Ward Councillor(s) to the Community Council and then to City Council for final decision, such delegation to come into effect on April 6, 2010.
2. the Deputy City Manager Cluster B report to the Planning and Growth Management Committee on possible amendments to the by-law and to Chapter 27, Council Procedures, of the City of Toronto Municipal Code which would implement Part 1 above.
12/7/2009 3:23:38 PM “PG33.10 - Jenkins 17A” 28 yea+13 nay,2/3 maj,quorum
YES Ainslie YES Bussin [Chair] YES Cho YES De Baeremaeker YES Del Grande YES Di Giorgio YES Filion YES Ford YES Heaps YES Holyday YES Jenkins YES Lee YES Lindsay Luby YES Mammoliti YES McConnell YES Mihevc YES Moeser YES Moscoe YES Nunziata YES Ootes YES Palacio YES Parker YES Perks YES Perruzza YES Saundercook YES Stintz YES Vaughan YES Walker NO Ashton NO Augimeri NO Carroll NO Davis NO Fletcher NO Giambrone NO Grimes NO Hall NO Kelly NO Milczyn NO Miller NO Minnan-Wong NO Rae
Motions Regarding the Proposed Tax
3a - Motion to Amend Item moved by Councillor Doug Holyday (Did not carry)
That City Council delete Recommendation 9 from the Planning and Growth Management Committee.
12/7/2009 3:28:33 PM “PG33.10 - Holyday 3A” 10 yea+31 nay,failed,quorum
YES Ainslie YES Del Grande YES Ford YES Holyday YES Lindsay Luby YES Mammoliti YES Minnan-Wong YES Nunziata YES Ootes YES Stintz NO Ashton NO Augimeri NO Bussin [Chair] NO Carroll NO Cho NO Davis NO De Baeremaeker NO Di Giorgio NO Filion NO Fletcher NO Giambrone NO Grimes NO Hall NO Heaps NO Jenkins NO Kelly NO Lee NO McConnell NO Mihevc NO Milczyn NO Miller NO Moeser NO Moscoe NO Palacio NO Parker NO Perks NO Perruzza NO Rae NO Saundercook NO Vaughan NO Walker
5 - Motion to Amend Item moved by Councillor Frances Nunziata (Did Not Carry)
That Recommendation 9 of the Planning and Growth Management Committee be deleted and replaced with the following:
9. The Deputy City Manager, Cluster B and the Deputy City Manager and Chief Financial Officer be directed to consult further with the industry on an appropriate Third Party Sign Tax rate.
12/7/2009 3:29:30 PM “PG33.10 - Nunziata 5” 11 yea+30 nay,failed,quorum
YES Del Grande YES Di Giorgio YES Ford YES Grimes YES Holyday YES Minnan-Wong YES Nunziata YES Ootes YES Parker YES Saundercook YES Stintz NO Ainslie NO Ashton NO Augimeri NO Bussin [Chair] NO Carroll NO Cho NO Davis NO De Baeremaeker NO Filion NO Fletcher NO Giambrone NO Hall NO Heaps NO Jenkins NO Kelly NO Lee NO Lindsay Luby NO Mammoliti NO McConnell NO Mihevc NO Milczyn NO Miller NO Moeser NO Moscoe NO Palacio NO Perks NO Perruzza NO Rae NO Vaughan NO Walker
19d - Motion to Amend Item moved by Councillor Adam Vaughan (Did Not Carry)
That Recommendation 4 from the Planning and Growth Management Committee be deleted and replaced as follows:
"4. City Council establish and adopt the following tax rates to be applied to the annual Third Party Sign Tax in accordance with the design features set out in Appendix E to the report (October 20, 2009) from the Deputy City Manager, Cluster B and the Deputy City Manager and Chief Financial Officer:
Class I Signs Class II Signs Class III Signs Class IV Signs Class V Signs
Pro-rated per
Sign - 2010 $1,290 $3,225 $5,5595 $12,375 $27,000
Rate per Sign –
2011 $1,725 $4,290 $7,440 $16,545 $36,105
12/7/2009 3:30:18 PM “PG33.10 - Vaughan 19D” 11 yea+30 nay,failed,quorum
YES Augimeri YES De Baeremaeker YES Filion YES Fletcher YES Giambrone YES Heaps YES McConnell YES Mihevc YES Moscoe YES Perks YES Vaughan NO Ainslie NO Ashton NO Bussin [Chair] NO Carroll NO Cho NO Davis NO Del Grande NO Di Giorgio NO Ford NO Grimes NO Hall NO Holyday NO Jenkins NO Kelly NO Lee NO Lindsay Luby NO Mammoliti NO Milczyn NO Miller NO Minnan-Wong NO Moeser NO Nunziata NO Ootes NO Palacio NO Parker NO Perruzza NO Rae NO Saundercook NO Stintz NO Walker
Recommendation 4 of the Supplementary Staff Report (November 27, 2009) (Carried)
4. City Council establish and adopt tax rates to be applied to the annual Third Party Sign Tax in accordance with the design features set out in Appendix E to the report (October 20, 2009) from the Deputy City Manager, Cluster B and the Deputy City Manager and Chief Financial Officer.
12/7/2009 3:31:17 PM “PG33.10 - Rec 4 -” 25 yea+16 nay,carried,quorum
YES Ashton YES Augimeri YES Bussin [Chair] YES Carroll YES Cho YES Davis YES De Baeremaeker YES Filion YES Fletcher YES Giambrone YES Hall YES Heaps YES Jenkins YES Mammoliti YES McConnell YES Mihevc YES Miller YES Moeser YES Moscoe YES Palacio YES Perks YES Perruzza YES Rae YES Vaughan YES Walker NO Ainslie NO Del Grande NO Di Giorgio NO Ford NO Grimes NO Holyday NO Kelly NO Lee NO Lindsay Luby NO Milczyn NO Minnan-Wong NO Nunziata NO Ootes NO Parker NO Saundercook NO Stintz
Part 3 of Kelly Motion 1 (Carried)
3. That Recommendation 9. be amended by deleting the words “July 1, 2010” and inserting the words “on the date the sign by-law comes into effect” so that such Recommendation 9. to read as follows:
"9. Council adopt an annual Third Party Sign Tax (the “TPST”), payable by all Third Party Sign Owners on each Third Party Sign owned by them, to be effective on the date the sign by-law comes into effect, in accordance with the design features set out in Appendix E to the report (October 20, 2009) from the Deputy City Manager, Cluster B and the Deputy City Manager and Chief Financial Officer, with the exception of the rates."
12/7/2009 3:32:29 PM “PG33.10 - Kelly 1 - Part 3” 22 yea+19 nay,carried,quorum
YES Augimeri YES Bussin [Chair] YES Carroll YES Cho YES Davis YES De Baeremaeker YES Filion YES Fletcher YES Giambrone YES Hall YES Jenkins YES Lindsay Luby YES McConnell YES Mihevc YES Miller YES Moeser YES Moscoe YES Perks YES Perruzza YES Rae YES Vaughan YES Walker NO Ainslie NO Ashton NO Del Grande NO Di Giorgio NO Ford NO Grimes NO Heaps NO Holyday NO Kelly NO Lee NO Mammoliti NO Milczyn NO Minnan-Wong NO Nunziata NO Ootes NO Palacio NO Parker NO Saundercook NO Stintz
Motions on the Proceeds of the Tax
18 - Motion to Amend Item moved by Councillor Shelley Carroll (Carried)
That City Council amend Recommendation 15 from the Planning and Growth Management Committee by deleting "to offset funding for City beautification and arts and culture initiatives, with a particular emphasis on visual and community arts", so that Recommendation 15 now reads:
"15. City Council allocate $1,413,600 from the revenues of the TPST towards repayment of the Public Realm Reserve Fund for the cost to secure space and equipment and program development costs and refer the remainder of the net revenues to the 2010 budget cycle."
12/7/2009 3:37:26 PM “PG33.10 - Carroll - 18” 35 yea+6 nay,2/3 maj,quorum
YES Ainslie YES Ashton YES Augimeri YES Bussin [Chair] YES Carroll YES Cho YES Davis YES De Baeremaeker YES Del Grande YES Di Giorgio YES Filion YES Giambrone YES Hall YES Heaps YES Holyday YES Jenkins YES Lee YES Lindsay Luby YES Mammoliti YES McConnell YES Mihevc YES Milczyn YES Miller YES Moeser YES Moscoe YES Nunziata YES Ootes YES Parker YES Perks YES Perruzza YES Rae YES Saundercook YES Stintz YES Vaughan YES Walker NO Fletcher NO Ford NO Grimes NO Kelly NO Minnan-Wong NO Palacio
Other motions related to the proceeds of the tax were not placed following the adoption of Councillor Carroll's motion
Other Motions
10b - Motion to Amend Motion moved by Councillor Karen Stintz (Did Not Carry)
That Motion 2b by Councillor Heaps be amended so that the information provided to staff be reprinted in summary form to the Planning and Growth Management Committee prior to the tax being implemented.
12/7/2009 3:41:12 PM “PG33.10 - Stintz 10B” 20 yea+21 nay,failed,quorum
YES Ainslie YES Ashton YES Del Grande YES Di Giorgio YES Ford YES Holyday YES Jenkins YES Kelly YES Lee YES Lindsay Luby YES Mammoliti YES Milczyn YES Minnan-Wong YES Nunziata YES Ootes YES Palacio YES Parker YES Saundercook YES Stintz YES Walker NO Augimeri NO Bussin [Chair] NO Carroll NO Cho NO Davis NO De Baeremaeker NO Filion NO Fletcher NO Giambrone NO Grimes NO Hall NO Heaps NO McConnell NO Mihevc NO Miller NO Moeser NO Moscoe NO Perks NO Perruzza NO Rae NO Vaughan
19a - Motion to Amend Motion moved by Councillor Adam Vaughan (Carried)
That Councillor Heaps' Motion 2b be amended by adding before the word "Auditors", the following:
"and 3rd party Auditors, to be"
so that the Motion now reads:
"That staff consider and report back to the Planning and Growth Management Committee, prior to the effective date of the tax only if any recommended amendments are required, to be based on any sign industry financial statements, including worksheets, and access to Auditors, and 3rd party Auditors, to be received before March 31, 2010."
- Adopted on a show of hands.
2b - Motion to Amend Item (Additional) moved by Councillor A.A. Heaps (Carried)
That a new Recommendation be added to read:
That staff consider and report back to the Planning and Growth Management Committee, prior to the effective date of the tax only if any recommended amendments are required, to be based on any sign industry financial statements, including worksheets, and access to Auditors, received before March 31, 2010.
12/7/2009 3:42:44 PM “PG33.10 - Heaps 2B as amended by Vaughan 19A” 26 yea+15 nay,carried,quorum
YES Ainslie YES Ashton YES Bussin [Chair] YES De Baeremaeker YES Del Grande YES Di Giorgio YES Ford YES Heaps YES Holyday YES Jenkins YES Kelly YES Lee YES McConnell YES Milczyn YES Minnan-Wong YES Moscoe YES Nunziata YES Ootes YES Palacio YES Parker YES Perks YES Perruzza YES Rae YES Saundercook YES Stintz YES Walker NO Augimeri NO Carroll NO Cho NO Davis NO Filion NO Fletcher NO Giambrone NO Grimes NO Hall NO Lindsay Luby NO Mammoliti NO Mihevc NO Miller NO Moeser NO Vaughan
12b - Motion to Amend Item (Additional) moved by Councillor Janet Davis (Carried)
That the Executive Director of Municipal Licencing and Standards be requested to report to the April 29, 2010 meeting of Licensing and Standards Committee on a mechanism to regulate control and/or eliminate third party signs/billboards on moving vehicles.
12/7/2009 3:44:03 PM “PG33.10 - Davis 12B” 27 yea+14 nay,carried,quorum
YES Ainslie YES Ashton YES Augimeri YES Bussin [Chair] YES Carroll YES Cho YES Davis YES De Baeremaeker YES Filion YES Fletcher YES Giambrone YES Hall YES Heaps YES Holyday YES Jenkins YES Lee YES McConnell YES Mihevc YES Miller YES Moeser YES Moscoe YES Nunziata YES Palacio YES Parker YES Perks YES Perruzza YES Walker NO Del Grande NO Di Giorgio NO Ford NO Grimes NO Kelly NO Lindsay Luby NO Mammoliti NO Milczyn NO Minnan-Wong NO Ootes NO Rae NO Saundercook NO Stintz NO Vaughan
14a - Motion to Amend Item (Additional) moved by Councillor Kyle Rae (Carried)
That the Deputy City Manager, Cluster B and the Deputy City Manager and Chief Financial Officer be requested to coordinate with MPAC to ensure that the assessment of property value with respect to signs is considered in the context of the tax adopted by Council.
- Adopted on a show of hands
14b - Motion to Amend Item (Additional) moved by Councillor Kyle Rae (Carried)
That the Deputy City Manager, Cluster B be directed to report back to the Planning and Growth Management Committee on possible amendments to the by-law to permit the installation of signs installed as a parapet above the level of the roof in exchange for the removal of an existing roof sign on the same premises.
12/7/2009 3:45:36 PM “PG33.10 - Rae 14B” 32 yea+9 nay,2/3 maj,quorum
YES Ainslie YES Ashton YES Augimeri YES Bussin [Chair] YES Carroll YES De Baeremaeker YES Del Grande YES Di Giorgio YES Fletcher YES Grimes YES Hall YES Heaps YES Jenkins YES Kelly YES Lee YES Mammoliti YES McConnell YES Milczyn YES Miller YES Minnan-Wong YES Moeser YES Nunziata YES Ootes YES Palacio YES Parker YES Perks YES Perruzza YES Rae YES Saundercook YES Stintz YES Vaughan YES Walker NO Cho NO Davis NO Filion NO Ford NO Giambrone NO Holyday NO Lindsay Luby NO Mihevc NO Moscoe
16 - Motion to Amend Item (Additional) moved by Councillor Paula Fletcher (Carried)
That the Deputy City Manager, Cluster B, report back to the Planning and Growth Management Committee on options to restrict signage in the waterfront area, including the possibility of establishing a Special Sign District to apply to the waterfront area.
12/7/2009 3:46:47 PM “PG33.10 - Fletcher 16” 37 yea+4 nay,2/3 maj,quorum
YES Ainslie YES Ashton YES Augimeri YES Bussin [Chair] YES Carroll YES Cho YES Davis YES De Baeremaeker YES Di Giorgio YES Filion YES Fletcher YES Giambrone YES Grimes YES Hall YES Heaps YES Holyday YES Jenkins YES Lee YES Lindsay Luby YES Mammoliti YES McConnell YES Mihevc YES Milczyn YES Miller YES Minnan-Wong YES Moeser YES Moscoe YES Nunziata YES Palacio YES Parker YES Perks YES Perruzza YES Rae YES Saundercook YES Stintz YES Vaughan YES Walker NO Del Grande NO Ford NO Kelly NO Ootes
19b - Motion to Amend Item moved by Councillor Adam Vaughan (Did Not Carry)
1. That, in the event that the New Sign Regulation and Revenue Strategy for the City of Toronto is subjected to a court challenge, no permits be issued or applications be received until such time as any legal action is resolved; and
2. That any legal fees or costs associated with a legal challenge be paid for by and increase to the new tax and the permit fees.
12/7/2009 3:47:37 PM “PG33.10 - Vaughan 19B” 13 yea+28 nay,failed,quorum
YES Augimeri YES Davis YES De Baeremaeker YES Filion YES Fletcher YES Hall YES McConnell YES Mihevc YES Moeser YES Moscoe YES Palacio YES Perks YES Vaughan NO Ainslie NO Ashton NO Bussin [Chair] NO Carroll NO Cho NO Del Grande NO Di Giorgio NO Ford NO Giambrone NO Grimes NO Heaps NO Holyday NO Jenkins NO Kelly NO Lee NO Lindsay Luby NO Mammoliti NO Milczyn NO Miller NO Minnan-Wong NO Nunziata NO Ootes NO Parker NO Perruzza NO Rae NO Saundercook NO Stintz NO Walker
Vote on the Balance of the Recommendations Contained in Supplementary item PG33.10(b) (Carried)
12/7/2009 3:49:20 PM “PG33.10 - Balance of the supplementary recs” 33 yea+8 nay,2/3 maj,quorum
YES Ainslie YES Ashton YES Augimeri YES Bussin [Chair] YES Carroll YES Cho YES Davis YES De Baeremaeker YES Di Giorgio YES Filion YES Fletcher YES Giambrone YES Grimes YES Hall YES Heaps YES Jenkins YES Kelly YES Lee YES Lindsay Luby YES Mammoliti YES McConnell YES Mihevc YES Milczyn YES Miller YES Moeser YES Moscoe YES Palacio YES Perks YES Perruzza YES Rae YES Saundercook YES Vaughan YES Walker NO Del Grande NO Ford NO Holyday NO Minnan-Wong NO Nunziata NO Ootes NO Parker NO Stintz
Vote on the item as amended (Carried)
12/7/2009 3:49:57 PM “PG33.10 - Adopt the item as amended” 29 yea+12 nay,2/3 maj,quorum
YES Ainslie YES Ashton YES Augimeri YES Bussin [Chair] YES Carroll YES Cho YES Davis YES De Baeremaeker YES Filion YES Fletcher YES Giambrone YES Grimes YES Hall YES Heaps YES Jenkins YES Lindsay Luby YES Mammoliti YES McConnell YES Mihevc YES Milczyn YES Miller YES Moeser YES Moscoe YES Palacio YES Perks YES Perruzza YES Rae YES Vaughan YES Walker NO Del Grande NO Di Giorgio NO Ford NO Holyday NO Kelly NO Lee NO Minnan-Wong NO Nunziata NO Ootes NO Parker NO Saundercook NO Stintz
Posts
